Week 5 NFL Betting Market Report & Actionable Insights w/ Mackenzie Rivers

NFL Week 5 Opening Line Report: How the Market Has Moved After Week 4

Each week, in this article, we will assess how the betting market has adjusted its expectations for the upcoming week’s games after digesting the latest batch of data from Thursday’s and Sunday’s finals. By comparing the lookahead lines with the current odds, we’ll break down how each team's performance and key injuries might have influenced the market's perception and the NFL betting landscape.

Going forward from Week 5 on, we will also provide the Summer Line to see how these teams have been re-evaluated on balance over the course of the season. However, note that the "verdict" provided will only assess how the teams have been re-assessed as a result of the prior week's action.

Please note: Lines are from the home team's perspective and rounded to the nearest half-point, except for when the line is near 3.

Thursday

TB @ ATL (8:15 ET / Amazon)

• Summer Line (as of July 1st): ATL -3
• Final Look Ahead Line (Saturday night of Week 4): ATL -3
• World Opener (Sunday afternoon): ATL -2.5
• Current (Monday 2PM ET): ATL -2.5

The Buccaneers' offense looked its best since Week 1, with Baker Mayfield rediscovering his chemistry with both Mike Evans and Chris Godwin in Week 4, leading to a much more consistent and explosive passing game. This resurgence came at the expense of the Eagles secondary, who had looked stout in their last outing vs. the Saints.. Meanwhile, the Falcons relied on two non-offensive touchdowns to secure a win over the Saints, masking a largely ineffective offensive performance led by Kirk Cousins, who had his worst game since Week 1 by both QBR and PFF passing grade. Tampa Bay's more reliable passing attack offers a sustainable path to future success, unlike the Falcons, whose recent victory seems less replicable. As a result, the market gave the Bucs a significant upgrade, moving them off the key number of +3.

Verdict (market adjustments from Week 4): Buccaneers upgraded 1 point, Falcons downgraded 1/2 point

Sunday

NYJ vs. MIN (930AM ET / NFL Network *London*)

• Summer Line: MIN +4
• Final Look Ahead Line: MIN +1
• World Opener: MIN -2.5
• Current: MIN -2.5

The Vikings have dominated all four games they’ve played this season, holding double-digit leads in the second half of each contest. No team has scored more than 10 points through three quarters against Minnesota, and on offense Sam Darnold has gone from being seen as a bust to entering the NFL MVP conversation. Meanwhile, the Jets' opponents are a combined 3-8 SU in their non-Jets matchups, and their offense has struggled all season, highlighted by a litany of false starts in their sloppy loss to the Broncos. While the head coach and quarterback volley blame back and forth on the cadence vs. no cadence debate, the fact remains that, despite their relatively easy schedule, Nathaniel Hackett's unit has failed to impress, with their only somewhat impressive offense performance coming in a highly advantageous Thursday night spot against a Patriots team coming off an overtime game. Prior to the season, the market viewed the Jets as contenders and the Vikings as also-rans, but that dynamic has flipped. The Vikings have earned a massive 6.5-point line shift since the market opened in May. Week 4 was particularly revealing for both teams, accounting for 3.5 points of that net adjustment.

Verdict: Vikings upgraded 1 point, Jets downgraded 1.5 points.

CAR @ CHI (1PM ET / FOX)

• Summer Line: CHI -5.5
• Final Look Ahead Line: CHI -3.5
• World Opener: CHI -4
• Current: CHI -4

The Bears’ defense and special teams continue to keep the team competitive in games, while their offense has struggled to find consistency despite several high-profile offseason acquisitions. However, the Bears’ rushing attack finally showed some signs of life in Week 4, leading to a slight upgrade for them in this matchup against the Panthers. On the other side, Carolina has played better overall since replacing Bryce Young with Andy Dalton at quarterback, but their defense still looks like one of the worst units in football.

Verdict: Bears upgraded 1/2 point

BAL @ CIN (1 PM ET / CBS)

• Summer Line: CIN +1
• Final Look Ahead Line: CIN +1
• World Opener: CIN +1.5
• Current: CIN +1.5

The Ravens dominated from start to finish on both sides of the ball against a Bills team that many considered to have the best power rating in the NFL entering Week 4. Their performance over the last two weeks—dominating playoff-caliber competition for 7 of the 8 quarters—has erased any lingering pessimism from their 0-2 start to the season. Meanwhile, the Bengals' offense continues to look solid, as they coasted to a 10-point win in Carolina. However, their vulnerability against the run will be put to the test against a Ravens team averaging 220 rushing yards per game.

Verdict: Ravens upgraded 1 point, Bengals upgraded ½ point.

BUF @ HOU (1PM ET / CBS)

• Summer Line: HOU -1.5
• Final Look Ahead Line: HOU +1.5
• World Opener (Sunday afternoon prior to SNF): HOU +2.5
• Current: HOU PK'em

The Texans' ground game has been abysmal since Joe Mixon went down, and despite CJ Stroud’s heroics, the Texans' offense hasn’t looked good since their Week 1 performance against the Colts. On the other side, the Bills have only had one significant hiccup on offense, but it was glaring, coming on Sunday Night Football with the world watching. The Bills' mounting injuries on defense may be a bigger concern, as the market has significantly downgraded Buffalo since the Ravens ran for 270+ yards en route to 35 points, which felt like it could have been even more.

Verdict: Texans 1/2 point downgrade, Bills 1.5-point downgrade.

IND @ JAX (1 PM ET / CBS)

• Summer Line: JAX -2.5
• Final Look Ahead Line: JAX -2.5
• World Opener: JAX -2.5
• Current: JAX -2.5 (-120)

Despite being 0-4, the Jaguars are still considered the better team compared to the Colts, even earning a slight net upgrade in this matchup from preseason expectations. On paper, the Jaguars have played well enough to win in three of their four games, a fact reflected in the market. Additionally, Doug Pederson is coaching for his job, as he is the undisputed favorite to be the first coach fired. The Colts are awaiting more information on the status of their starting QB, Anthony Richardson, who left Week 4 early with a hip injury.

Verdict: Colts 1/2 point downgrade, waiting for more info on Anthony Richardson status.

MIA @ NE (1 PM ET / FOX)

• Summer Line: NE +4.5
• Final Look Ahead Line: NE -1
• World Opener: NE +1
• Current: NE +1

The Patriots' offense continues to be one-dimensional. When turnovers are removed from the equation, they have the third least effective passing attack in the NFL by EPA/play, better only than the Broncos and Browns. Their running game has been a relative bright spot, but it still ranks 16th or exactly average by this metric and has been hampered by their best running back, Rhamondre Stevenson, fumbling at least once in every game this season. Meanwhile, optimism is growing among teammates and bettors regarding the introduction of one-time Pro Bowl quarterback Tyler Huntley into the mix for Miami. The Dolphins saw a 2-point net upgrade for both their Monday Night Football matchup against the Titans in Week 4 and this Week 5 matchup after Huntley took over as the team's starting QB.

Verdict: Patriots downgraded 1 point, Dolphins to play on MNF*.

CLE @ WAS (1 PM ET / FOX)

• Summer Line: WAS +3
• Final Look Ahead Line: WAS -1
• World Opener: WAS -3
• Current: WAS-3

Over the course of this season, the Vegas market has massively upgraded the Commanders due to their record-setting offense under rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels and new play caller Kliff Kingsbury. Daniels has posted an NFL-best 82.1% completion rate—the highest ever for any quarterback through four weeks—becoming only the second to complete over 80% of his passes in a four-game stretch, joining Peyton Manning. He’s also led Washington to an 85.3% down set conversion rate, ranking among the top five since 2007. As a result, the Commanders have moved from +3 in the summer lines to -3 after Week 4, with a significant ~3-point jump following their dominant victory over the Cardinals. Meanwhile, Cleveland's offense continued to flounder in their loss in Las Vegas. Washington’s offense currently ranks first in EPA per play, while the Browns’ offense has struggled, ranking 30th in the same metric. Despite Washington’s defense ranking last in EPA per play allowed, the market views their offense as the more predictive factor, resulting in their net upgrade of over a touchdown in this match-up from preseason expectations.

Verdict: Commanders 2-point upgrade, Browns 1-point downgrade.

LV @ DEN (4:05PM ET / FOX)

• Summer Line: DEN -1
• Final Look Ahead Line: DEN -1.5
• World Opener: DEN -2
• Current: DEN -2.5

Despite both teams winning and covering, the Broncos received significantly more credit from the market after pulling off a massive road upset over the Jets. Denver’s defense, particularly their pass defense, remains one of the best in football. On the other hand, the Raiders' win against Cleveland could easily have gone the other way, with Amari Cooper dropping a key pass that led to a pivotal interception, and a highly questionable holding call in the 4th quarter that negated a 75-yard touchdown to Cooper. The Raiders, under Antonio Pierce, are 9-3-1 ATS, yet they still appear very beatable. Notably, Las Vegas has won their last eight matchups against the Broncos, going 7-1 ATS in that span. However, the market currently gives Las Vegas only a ~46% chance to keep that winning streak alive in Denver this Sunday.

Verdict: Broncos upgraded 1 point.

ARI @ SF (4:05PM ET / FOX)

• Summer Line: SF -9.5
• Final Look Ahead Line: SF -6.5
• World Opener: SF -7
• Current: SF -7.5

The 49ers boast the NFL’s leading passer in Brock Purdy, the top rusher in Jordan Mason, and arguably the best defensive player in the league in Fred Warner. Despite this, they are only 2-2 SU and ATS and have disappointed on balance from their sky high preseason expectations, which is reflected from the net downgrade of 2-points from the summer line. With Deebo Samuel and George Kittle back in Week 4, the 49ers looked much more like their old selves, though this was against one of the league's worst teams in the Patriots. On the other hand, the Cardinals were routed at home by a Commanders team that, while expected to struggle, continues to set offensive records. Without his former play-caller Kliff Kingsbury, who is now thriving in Washington, Kyler Murray has slowed down significantly after leading the league in QBR through the first two weeks of the season. The market responded from the Week 4 results by upgrading the 49ers by more than a point in this match-up, moving them through the key number of 7.

Verdict: 49ers upgraded 1/2 point, Cardinals dowgraded 1 point.

GB @ LAR (4:25 PM ET / CBS)

• Summer Line: LAR -1.5
• Final Look Ahead Line: LAR +3.5
• World Opener: LAR +3.5
• Current: LAR +3.5

Both teams underperformed in Week 4, with Jordan Love looking particularly rusty in his first game back from injury. For the Rams, Matthew Stafford made some uncharacteristic mistakes against the Bears as he continues to struggle behind a makeshift offensive line and without his top two pass catchers, who remain sidelined due to injury. One bright spot for the Rams has been TuTu Atwell, who has more than doubled his receiving yards Over/Under in each of the last two weeks, becoming Stafford's primary target. Despite the slow starts, bettors seem to have liked what they saw from both offenses in the second half of Week 4, as the total has been bet up 1.5 points to 48 since the market opened on Sunday afternoon.

Verdict: No change resulting from Week 4 action.

NYG @ SEA (4:25 PM ET / CBS)

• Summer Line: SEA -3.5
• Final Look Ahead Line: SEA -6.5
• World Opener: SEA -6
• Current: SEA -6

The market has oscillated here as both teams lost iDespite the home loss on Thursday Night Football, the connection between Daniel Jones and Malik Nabors looks legitimate. Jones threw for his most passing yards in his last nine games against the Cowboys, leading to a slight market upgrade for the Giants in this matchup. Meanwhile, the market remains cautious regarding the Seahawks' 3-0 record, as they have yet to face a team with both their starting quarterback and a preseason win total over 6.5. The Seahawks' Monday Night Football game will be their first true test of the season.

Verdict: Giants upgraded 1/2 point, Seahawks to play on MNF*.

SNF: DAL @ PIT (8:20 PM ET / NBC)

• Summer Line: PIT +1.5
• Final Look Ahead Line: PIT -2.5
• World Opener: PIT -2.5
• Current: PIT -2.5

Out of necessity, Justin Fields was unleashed in an effort to come back from a 17-point deficit against the Colts in Week 3. The results were mixed, as Fields threw for over 300 yards but also had a costly fumble while trying to extend a play 20 yards behind the line of scrimmage. Meanwhile, the Cowboys got back to .500 with their Thursday Night Football win over the Giants but still appear one-dimensional on offense, ranking last in the league in rushing yards per game (75.3) through four weeks. This is a stark contrast from their early days with Dak Prescott and Ezekiel Elliott, when the Cowboys leaned heavily on their running game.

Verdict: No change resulting from Week 4 action.

Monday

MNF: NOR @ KC (8:15 PM ET / ESPN)

• Summer Line: KC -8
• Final Look Ahead Line: KC -6
• World Opener: KC -5.5
• Current: KC -5

The Chiefs secured their 10th consecutive win, but it came at a cost as their top wide receiver, Rashee Rice, tore his ACL. Kansas City's scoring output has decreased each week this season, dropping from 27 in Week 1, to 26 in Week 2, to 22 in Week 3, and finally to 17 in their Week 4 win over the Chargers. As a result, the market has downgraded them considerably despite their undefeated record. It will require some patented genius from Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes to reverse this downward trend without their top RB and top 2 WRs. On the other side, the Saints' offense has also looked significantly diminished over the last two weeks after starting the season on fire. Time will tell if their offensive slowdown is more related to their offensive line injuries or if the league has caught up with new offensive coordinator Klint Kubiak's tactics.

Verdict: Chiefs 1-point downgrade, resulting largely from cluster injuries now without their best two WRs from preseason expectation in Hollywood Brown and Rashee Rice both likely done for the year.

Our NFL Premium Package is now available for the 2024 season! The Betting Predators NFL Premium Package was created to give you with the highest-quality NFL betting and player prop analysis. We're here to help you save time, win money and overall become a long-term profitable sports bettor.

Our team of professional bettors and handicappers, led by Mackenzie Rivers, Chris Dell and Smoove, deliver real-time best bets and player props, all in one place, through the end of the Super Bowl each season.